Well, I’m back in the States for the holidays. Spending time with family has kept me away from the laptop. We will be traveling this week to visit my sister in Denver, so there will less time for blogging. So, I’m going to lean on one of my favorite Bible teachers, Chuck Missler.
As I write, the first night of Hanukkah is drawing to a close. Hanukkah is a Jewish festival. You won’t find it in the Tanakh (what we Christians call the Old Testament). However, you will find it in the B’rit Hadashah (New Testament). What?
And it was at Jerusalem the feast of the dedication, and it was winter. –John 10:22 KJV
A while back I posted on the beginning of the Advent season and the Second Coming of Yeshua. Read on to see how Hanukkah has a link to Matthew 24. (The read is long and a bit academic, so go ahead and get a cup of your favorite hot drink and some cookies.)
by Chuck Missler/Kononia House
Each year, around the time we prepare to celebrate Christmas, our Jewish friends celebrate Hanukkah.
It may come as a surprise to many of our readers that this holiday is alluded to in the New Testament. (Whereas Christmas is not: the observation of Christmas began in 354 A.D. from an adaptation of established pagan holidays. While there are several defendable estimates regarding the birthday of Christ, we know it was not in winter: the flocks were in open field, indicating sometime prior to October.)
In fact, Hanukkah highlights an historical event that Jesus Himself pointed to as the key to understanding the prophecies concerning His return!
The Mystery in John 10
John Chapter 10 is, of course, the famous Good Shepherd discourse. It clearly speaks for itself and won’t be dealt with here. Verse 22, however, seems to be a strange inclusion: right in the middle of this chapter the Holy Spirit notes the following:
And it was at Jerusalem the feast of dedication, and it was winter. John 10:22
Why is this reference here?
The Importance of our Approach
The most important discovery of my life was the insight that the Bible is an integrated message system. Although these 66 books were written by over 40 authors over thousands of years, we discover that they are a unified whole. Every word, every number, every place name, even the implied punctuation, appear to be the result of supernatural engineering. The rabbis in Israel have a quaint way of expressing this. They say that we won’t really understand the Scriptures until the Messiah comes. But when He comes, He will not only interpret the passages for us; He will interpret the very words; He will interpret the very letters; He will even interpret the spaces between the letters!
I used to think this was just a colorful exaggeration. Until I re-read Jesus’ own comments on the Scripture:
Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets; I am not come to destroy, but to fulfill. For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one yot or one tittle shall in no way pass from the law, till all be fulfilled. Matthew 5:17-18
A “yot” or a “tittle” are Hebraisms: a “yot” is one of the 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet that we might mistake for an apostrophe, or a blemish on the paper. A “tittle” is a tiny notation that distinguishes some of the letters. The phrase that Jesus used is equivalent to our “dotting of an ‘i’ or the crossing of a ‘t.'” These words, from our Lord Himself, seem to verify the rather extreme view of the rabbis.
Thus we discover that every detail of the Bible is there by design. This insight opens an entirely new dimension of Bible study. Every time you find a “mistake” or “contradiction” in the Bible, rejoice: there is a discovery behind that ostensible discrepancy.
The Feast of Dedication
Since we have concluded that nothing in Scripture is accidental or trivial, why does this detail in John 10:22 exist? What is the “feast of dedication”? The dedication is of the Temple, of course. But let’s explore this further.
There have been only two Temples: the original one built by Solomon, which was ultimately destroyed by the Babylonians; and Nehemiah’s, which was built when the captives returned after the Babylonian Captivity. (This “Second Temple” was subsequently expanded by Herod and was the Temple in place during the New Testament period.) Solomon’s Temple was dedicated in the month of Ethanim, or Tishri.1 This can’t be the reference we’re looking for since this was in the autumn. John 10:22 alludes specifically to a feast of dedication in winter. Nehemiah’s Temple was dedicated in the month of Adar.2 So this can’t be it either since Adar is in the spring. Now we’re really puzzled! The key to this riddle requires some important historical background.
An Historical Reference
A century earlier, in 168 B.C., the Seleucid ruler Antiochus IV (“Epiphanes”)3 son of Antiochus the Great, became the successor of his brother, Seleucus IV, who had been murdered by his minister, Heliodorus, as king of Syria (175-164 B.C.). Antiochus was an eccentric, cruel and tyrannical despot. He undertook the total eradication of the Jewish religion and the establishment of Greek polytheism in its stead.
The observance of all Jewish laws, especially those relating to the Sabbath and to circumcision, were forbidden under penalty of death. Representatives of the crown everywhere enforced the edict. Once a month a search was instituted, and whoever had secreted a copy of the Law or had observed the rite of circumcision was condemned to death. He pillaged the city of Jerusalem, took 10,000 captives, stripped the Temple of its treasures, and built a pagan altar on the Great Altar of Burnt Sacrifices.4
On the 25th of Chislev (Antiochus’ birthday), sacrifice was brought on this altar for the first time.5 He required a swine to be offered in every village.6 (If you know how the Jews feel about pork, you can imagine how that went over! But that’s not all)
He also erected an idol to Zeus in the Holy of Holies.7 This desecrating sacrilege has a technical name: “the abomination of desolation.”
In the village of Modein, an aged priest named Mattathias lived with his five sons. When officers arrived to carry out Antiochus’ decrees, Mattathias killed both the first Jew who approached the pagan altar to offer sacrifice and the royal official who presided, and Mattathias and his sons fled to the hills. This spontaneous revolt grew into a full-scale uprising: Mattathias and his five sons became the nucleus of a growing band of rebels against Antiochus.
Mattathias died soon after, leaving leadership in the hands of his son Judas, whose nickname “Maccabeus” (“the hammer”) became the source of the popular name given to the family and its followers. Under Judas’ brilliant leadership, what had begun as a guerrilla war turned into full-scale military engagements in which the smaller Jewish forces managed to defeat the much more powerful Syrian armies, and they succeeded in throwing off the yoke of the Seleucid Empire.
On the third anniversary of the desecration of the Temple, on the 25th of Kislev, 164 B.C., the Temple worship was reestablished. The altar and all of the vessels used in the earlier sacrilege were destroyed and replaced with new ones, and the Temple was rededicated. It is this rededication that is still celebrated among the Jews to this very day as Hanukkah.
A Key Technical Term
The desecration of the Temple in 167 B.C. included the definitive event known as the “abomination of desolation.” The term “abomination” in the Bible is a common term for idol worship. The “abomination of desolation” refers to the ultimate extreme form of idol worship: placing an idol on the most sacred spot on Planet Earth: in Jerusalem, in the Temple precincts, in the Holy of Holies itself!
So why did the Holy Spirit highlight Hanukkah by alluding to it in the New Testament? Because Jesus Himself pointed to this specific historical detail as the key to understanding prophecy concerning the Last Days.
A Private Briefing
Four disciples came to Jesus privately, asking Him about His “Second Coming.” His response is so significant that it is recorded in two of the Gospels: Matthew and Mark.8 (A similar account in Luke actually focuses on some different elements.)
He opened this briefing with a series of “non-signs”: certain things that will occur “but the end is not yet.” Then He highlighted a critical event as the key to the prophecy:
When you, therefore, shall see the abomination of desolation, spoken of by Daniel the prophet, stand in the holy place (whosoever readeth, let him understand), then let them who are in Judea flee into the mountains; Let him who is on the housetop not come down to take anything out of his house; Neither let him who is in the field return back to take his clothes. Matthew 24:15-18
In other words, when this event happens, it will be essential for them to get out Judea immediately! (You are also “on the spot”: if you read that verse you are under His orders to “understand”!)
An Essential Insight
Jesus did us all an enormous favor in verse 15. He saved each of us many hours of tedious library research! He attributed the Book of Daniel to Daniel the prophet. (It happens that Daniel is one of the best-documented books of the Old Testament, but Jesus gave us a great short cut. Anyone who believes in Jesus Christ has no problem with authorship of Daniel…anyone who doesn’t believe in Jesus Christ has much bigger problems than the authorship of the Book of Daniel!)
Jesus’ reference to the “abomination of desolation” was, of course, made two centuries after the historical event now commemorated at Hanukkah. He was speaking of a similar event yet future.
Other Attempts Frustrated
In about 40 A.D. Caligula ordered his image to be installed in the Holy of Holies. Petronius, his general in Judea, realizing how vehement the Jews’ reaction would be, declined to execute the order. When Caligula found out, he ordered the death of Petronius. But Caligula died a few weeks later, and due to a mix-up at sea, the message that Caligula had died preceded the order for Petronius’ execution, so he got off the hook.
It is interesting how God intervened to prevent another desecration of the Temple from happening. Has it happened yet?
The Destruction of the Second Temple
Just as Jesus had predicted, in 69 A.D. the 5th, 10th, 12th, and 15th Roman Legions, under Titus Vespasian, laid siege to Jerusalem. Over a million men, women and children were slaughtered in that terrible war. Finally, on the 9th of Av, 70 A.D., the Temple was destroyed.9 It was this event that Luke’s account focuses on. Both Luke and Matthew highlight a group of signs, which Matthew dubs as “the beginning of sorrows”:
And ye shall hear of wars and rumours of wars: see that ye be not troubled: for all these things must come to pass, but the end is not yet. For nation shall rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom: and there shall be famines, and pestilences, and earthquakes, in divers places. All these are the beginning of sorrows. Matthew 24:6-8
Matthew’s account focuses on what follows this group of signs.10 Luke focuses on the what precedes these signs.11 He warned his audience that when Jerusalem was surrounded by armies, they were to get out of town and don’t let any in the hills go back to town. Luke tells his audience that “this generation will not pass until all be fulfilled,”12 and 38 years later – the same length of the generation that died in the wilderness – Jerusalem fell in 70 A.D.
A Critical Hiatus
The Emperor Nero had ordered his general, Vespasian, and his son Titus, to use force to get things in Judea under control. They had conquered the towns in the Galilee and were preparing to take Jerusalem next. But then Nero died. In Rome, Galba, Otho, and Vitelius vied for the throne; in the subsequent confusion and ambiguity, Vespasian went to Rome and succeeded to take the throne as Emperor. His son Titus was left to complete the siege of Jerusalem.
During the hiatus, Christians, following the warnings in the Luke account, escaped to the mountains in Pella in Perea, and not one perished.13
A Misleading View
There are those who view the destruction of the Temple in 70 A.D. as the “abomination of desolation.” There are several problems with this view.
First, there was a war going on. There was no opportunity for the Romans to install false worship of any kind inside the Temple. The Temple was inadvertently set on fire, and the interior, which was wood overlaid with gold, burned thus melting the gold. The soldiers were ordered to take it apart stone by stone to recover the gold, just as Jesus had predicted.14 All of this was well documented by an eyewitness, Flavius Josephus, whose classic works are readily available. 15
The view that the abomination of desolation has already occurred, in addition to being historically inaccurate, also requires the bizarre allegorization of the rest of Jesus’ presentation. (Matthew 24:29-31 hasn’t happened yet; at least, not so you’d notice!)
The abomination of desolation didn’t happen in 70 A.D., and it couldn’t have happened over the subsequent 1900 years because there has been no Temple in Jerusalem to be thus defiled. It remains the key milestone to trigger the exodus of those believers remaining in Jerusalem at that time. Every year at the celebration of Hanukkah we need to recall this background and reflect on its prophetic significance!
A Third Temple Needed
When will it happen? When there is, once again, a Temple in Jerusalem. Three times in the New Testament there is reference to the rebuilding of the Temple prior to the Second Coming of Christ.16
Despite an untenable political climate on the Temple Mount, there are preparations underway in anticipation of a rebuilt Temple. In Yeshivas in Jerusalem, over 200 priests are presently in training. Almost all of the required implements have been fabricated by the Temple Institute.
There is a search going on for the right marine snails to yield the Levitical blue and the royal purple. Ground-penetrating radar and infrared recordings are being used to find the precise foundations of the original Temples. The preparations continue despite the political uncertainties.
The scientists and archaeologists will be giving us an update at the Jerusalem Temple Conference being held this coming March. (Pray about joining us. See here.)
The Holiday Message
The Holy Spirit put John 10:22 in the New Testament to highlight Daniel’s famous prophecy and to focus our attention on this key milestone in the end-time scenario. So as your Jewish friends celebrate Hanukkah this year, let this commemoration also remind you that preparations are presently underway to set the stage for the final countdown. What an exciting time to be alive!
Behold ye among the heathen, and regard, and wonder marvelously: for I will work a work in your days, which ye will not believe, though it be told you. Habakkuk 1:5
- 1 Kings 8:2. Ethanim is the same as Tishri, or September-October
- Ezra 6:15, 16. Adar is typically in early March.
- “Epiphanes” is an abbreviation of Greek: theos epiphanes, a designation he gave himself: “the god who appears or reveals himself.”
- Josephus, Antiquities, XII v 4.
- 1 Maccabees 1:54,59.
- Josephus, Antiquities, XII v 4.
- 1 Maccabees 1:54; 2 Maccabees 6:1-7.
- Matthew 24, 25; Mark 13, 14; Luke’s similar account was given to a different audience on a different occasion and did not focus on the same issues.
- The very day on the Jewish calendar that Nebuchadnezzar destroyed the Temple in 537 b.c.
- Matthew 24:8,9.
- Luke 21:12.
- Luke 21:32.
- Eusebius, Book III, 5.1.
- Luke 19:43,44.
- Josephus, Wars of the Jews, VI, vi, 1.
- Matthew 24:15; 2 Thess 2:4; Revelation 11:1-2.